TY - JOUR
T1 - A Trans-Atlantic, Expert-Based, Delphi Consensus Document on controversial issues in the management of patients with chronic limb-threatening ischemia
AU - Paraskevas, Kosmas I.
AU - Conte, Michael S.
AU - Trans-Atlantic VAScular COnsortium (TAVASCO) Working Group
AU - Spinelli, Francesco
AU - Farber, Alik
AU - Blecha, Matthew
AU - Malas, Mahmoud B.
AU - Dardik, Alan
AU - Perler, Bruce A.
AU - Scali, Salvatore
AU - Debus, E. Sebastian
AU - Zeller, Thomas
AU - Abularrage, Christopher J.
AU - Torsello, Giovanni B.
AU - Chakfe, Nabil
AU - White, John V.
AU - van den Berg, Jos C.
AU - Zeebregts, Clark J.
AU - Troisi, Nicola
AU - Vega DE Ceniga, Melina
AU - Stilo, Francesco
AU - D'Oria, Mario
AU - Dermody, Meghan
AU - Myrcka, Piotr
AU - Noronen, Katariina M.
AU - Ricco, Jean Baptiste
AU - Zayed, Hany
AU - Bosiers, Michel J.
AU - Morgan, Robert A.
AU - Migliara, Bruno
AU - Hicks, Caitlin W.
AU - Sultan, Sherif A.
AU - Secemsky, Eric A.
AU - Mansilha, Armando
AU - Reijnen, Michel M.
AU - Verhagen, Hence J.
AU - Gargiulo, Mauro
AU - Faggioli, Gianluca
AU - Goudot, Guillaume
AU - Valenti, Domenico
AU - Behrendt, Christian Alexander
AU - Setacci, Carlo
AU - Svetlikov, Alexei
AU - Pecoraro, Felice
AU - Bisdas, Theodosios
AU - Schmidt, Andrej
AU - Jawien, Arkadiusz
AU - Csobay-Novak, Csaba
AU - Vermassen, Frank E.
AU - Tulamo, Riikka
AU - Szeberin, Zoltan
PY - 2026/8/1
Y1 - 2026/8/1
N2 - BACKGROUND: Two recent multicenter randomized controlled trials (RCTs) compared best endovascular treatment versus surgical revascularization for patients with chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI) and reached opposite conclusions. The aim of this international, expert-based Delphi Consensus document was to address these conflicting results and to explore their interpretation and applicability in the real-world clinical practice.METHODS: A three-round Delphi Consensus document was completed by 51 European and 17 USA-based experts addressing five pre-specified CLTI clinical scenarios and two questions regarding the applicability of the two RCTs. All answers were provided anonymously. The response rate for each round was 100%. Consensus was reached when ≥70% of the participants agreed on a response showing preference for a specific approach. RESULTS: Most participants (43/68; 63.3%) preferred a venous bypass for a patient with segmental occlusions of the lower limb arteries and an available distal target vessel, although this did not reach consensus. In contrast, consensus was achieved (49/68; 72.2%) for a diabetic patient with occlusion of all three infrapopliteal vessels for whom most experts favored angioplasty of any possible tibial artery. In case of previous endovascular recanalization failure, options were divided between repeat angioplasty (27 of 68; 39.7%) and venous bypass (35 of 68; 51.5%). The majority of participants reported that their approach had not changed following publication of the two RCTs (50 of 68; 73.5%) and did not believe that the trials had changed significantly the management of patients with CLTI in their clinical practice (53 of 68; 77.9%). In a subgroup analysis comparing European vs. USA-based physicians, there were minor differences in specific topics.CONCLUSIONS:In the present Expert-based Consensus document, considerable heterogeneity was found between USA-based and European participants on several topics related to CLTI and consensus was not always achieved. Endovascular and open surgical techniques should be regarded as complementary strategies, rather than as competing alternatives. Treatment should be individualized based on individual patient anatomy, extent of ischemia, presence of tissue loss, foot infection and conduit availability.
AB - BACKGROUND: Two recent multicenter randomized controlled trials (RCTs) compared best endovascular treatment versus surgical revascularization for patients with chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI) and reached opposite conclusions. The aim of this international, expert-based Delphi Consensus document was to address these conflicting results and to explore their interpretation and applicability in the real-world clinical practice.METHODS: A three-round Delphi Consensus document was completed by 51 European and 17 USA-based experts addressing five pre-specified CLTI clinical scenarios and two questions regarding the applicability of the two RCTs. All answers were provided anonymously. The response rate for each round was 100%. Consensus was reached when ≥70% of the participants agreed on a response showing preference for a specific approach. RESULTS: Most participants (43/68; 63.3%) preferred a venous bypass for a patient with segmental occlusions of the lower limb arteries and an available distal target vessel, although this did not reach consensus. In contrast, consensus was achieved (49/68; 72.2%) for a diabetic patient with occlusion of all three infrapopliteal vessels for whom most experts favored angioplasty of any possible tibial artery. In case of previous endovascular recanalization failure, options were divided between repeat angioplasty (27 of 68; 39.7%) and venous bypass (35 of 68; 51.5%). The majority of participants reported that their approach had not changed following publication of the two RCTs (50 of 68; 73.5%) and did not believe that the trials had changed significantly the management of patients with CLTI in their clinical practice (53 of 68; 77.9%). In a subgroup analysis comparing European vs. USA-based physicians, there were minor differences in specific topics.CONCLUSIONS:In the present Expert-based Consensus document, considerable heterogeneity was found between USA-based and European participants on several topics related to CLTI and consensus was not always achieved. Endovascular and open surgical techniques should be regarded as complementary strategies, rather than as competing alternatives. Treatment should be individualized based on individual patient anatomy, extent of ischemia, presence of tissue loss, foot infection and conduit availability.
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105051823393
U2 - 10.23736/S0392-9590.26.05593-8
DO - 10.23736/S0392-9590.26.05593-8
M3 - Article
C2 - 42803200
AN - SCOPUS:105051823393
SN - 0392-9590
VL - 45
SP - 287
EP - 296
JO - International angiology : a journal of the International Union of Angiology
JF - International angiology : a journal of the International Union of Angiology
IS - 4
ER -