Assessment of pain: can caregivers or relatives rate pain in nursing home residents?

R (Rhodee) van Herk, Monique van Dijk, N Biemold, Dick Tibboel, FPM (Frans) Baar, R (Rianne) Wit

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

20 Citations (Scopus)


Aim. To compare pain reports of nursing home residents to ratings by proxies. Background. It is not easy to assess pain in cognitively impaired residents. For residents who are unable to report pain intensity themselves, proxies (i.e. relatives or caregivers) might serve as sources of information. The utility of these proxies in assessing residents' pain is not clear however. Design. A multicenter cross-sectional study. Methods. Pain intensity was rated on a Numeric Rating Scale; proxies were asked how certain they were about their observations. Agreements on ratings were computed by means of intra class correlation (ICC) coefficients for continuous variables and multiple linear regression analyses were performed with the level of pain intensity by proxies as the dependent variable. Results. The sample consisted of 174 residents (median age 82 years), of whom 124 were cognitively impaired and 50 intact, and 293 proxies: 171 caregivers and 122 relatives. All three parties reported median pain intensity during the preceding week as 6 center dot 0. Data were consistent with low-to-moderate correlation coefficients between residents and caregivers (ICC = -0 center dot 12 to 0 center dot 25), residents and relatives (ICC = -0 center dot 51 to 0 center dot 48) and caregivers and relatives (ICC = 0 center dot 03 to 0 center dot 31). Residents themselves judged pain intensity at rest significantly higher than did proxies (p = 0 center dot 05). Caregivers scored significantly higher ratings for residents on analgesics (p = 0 center dot 001) and significantly lower pain ratings if they were more satisfied with the prescribed analgesics (p = 0 center dot 01). Conclusions. Proxy report of relatives and caregivers on presence and intensity of pain is unreliable, especially for cognitively impaired persons. The use of a standardised pain observation scale could be helpful. Relevance to clinical practice. Pain management in nursing home residents could be improved by educating caregivers about assessment and treatment of chronic pain. Relatives should be informed about chronic pain and learn how to alleviate pain through non-pharmacological interventions.
Original languageUndefined/Unknown
Pages (from-to)2478-2485
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Clinical Nursing
Issue number17
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Cite this