Three-Dimensional Bioprinting of Regenerative Cartilage Constructs with Directional Ionically Derived Stiffness Gradients

Tissue engineering approaches for cartilage tissue regeneration are expanding to include the complex features of the tissue, such as the biological and mechanical gradients. Many of these approaches are, however, based on the use of multiple biomaterials or concentrations, and crosslinking methods that make it difficult to integrate and control the properties of the resulting scaffolds. In this study, a 3D bioprinted scaffold with a stiffness gradient was fabricated by using a single biomaterial type and concentration combined with a directional ionic crosslinking method. The scaffolds revealed a gradient in stiffness from 39.8 ± 6.6 kPa at the top to 60.6 ± 10.9 kPa at the bottom of the scaffolds. Live/dead analysis of human chondrocytes embedded in the scaffolds showed no negative effects of the stiffness gradient on cell viability over 28 days. The induced stiffness gradient led to a gradient in cell density and sulfated glycosaminoglycan deposition in the bioprinted tissue constructs with enhanced values in the softer top region of the scaffolds as compared to the stiffer bottom part. This study showed a novel method to generate scaffolds with stiffness gradients from a single biomaterial and indicates that such scaffolds could be used to spatially regulate the behavior of chondrocytes and the associated deposition of the cartilage matrix.